Ticket #13 (defect)
Opened 3 years ago
NSEC3 hashes have owner names whose existence is denied
Status: new
| Reported by: | ben | Assigned to: | ben |
|---|---|---|---|
| Priority: | normal | Milestone: | |
| Component: | drafts | Version: | |
| Severity: | normal | Keywords: | |
| Cc: |
No one has yet to present a technical argument on how this is a problem. Peter Koch felt that we don't know yet whether this will be a problem and as such we can't summarily dismiss it. Especially considering we have a precedent of ignoring "problems" that have come back to haunt us. He has half-seriously proposed on the mailing list a solution involving using a new label type. Olafur Gudmundsson felt that we should do some experimentation to better determine if this will be a problem and keep this issue open until then. Olaf Kolkman said that the working group has agreed that for this document, it will not proceed until and engineering workshop has occurred and code has been tested. Ben Laurie stated that there are 3 implementations close to being completed. Ed Lewis said he won't consider this issue closed until he sees it in working operation. Russ Mundy said he wants the working group to figure out a way we can move forward. Mark Andrews stated that there is a way to do this that will have zero impact on the namespace of the zone.
David Blacka has proposed a mechanism which will fix this problem almost everywhere. He and I will write it up.
